Rapid Insights: ‘His & Hers’ Shows Why One Unreliable Narrator Isn’t Enough

Who’s been tuning in for this twisty thriller? 
Women, predominantly. His & Hers pulls 60% female viewers and skews heavily 30+ (83%), though it’s slightly less female-skewing than most mysteries in this category, likely because Jon Bernthal’s detective Jack shares equal narrative weight with Tessa Thompson’s Anna. For comparison, Stay Close (67% women / 72% aged 30+) and Peacock’s All Her Fault (65% women / 77% aged 35+) both center more heavily on female protagonists.

Why are viewers pressing play?
For the darkness hiding beneath small-town civility. His & Hers‘ top ratings driver is Dark Secrets (139), and the show delivers in spades as both Anna and Jack wade through a minefield of lies about their hometown, their failed marriage, and the string of murdered women who all knew them both. The series explores Work-Life Balance (129) with a dangerous twist (Anna chooses to report on murders tied to her own past, while Jack investigates crimes that point to his seeming culpability). Audiences are drawn to the show’s promise of Hidden Truth (122), watching each episode methodically peel back another layer of deception in what seemed like an idyllic Georgia town.

What’s keeping audiences hooked episode after episode?
The he-said, she-said structure. His & Hers employs dueling Voice-Over Narration (120) from both Anna and Jack, letting viewers experience the same investigation through two completely unreliable perspectives (each hiding secrets, each suspecting the other). The Small Town Life (118) setting of Dahlonega creates the claustrophobic pressure cooker essential to great thrillers, where everybody knows everybody’s business and old wounds fester for decades. The brutal Murder (117) in the premiere kicks off a chain of killings all connected to Anna’s high school past, while the Estranged Relationship (116) between the two leads adds delicious tension as they’re forced into proximity despite their bitter separation. Personal Revelations (114) about the victims (all women from Anna’s former mean-girl clique) drop like bombs, making it nearly impossible to stop watching as motives multiply and the body count climbs.

What gives His & Hers staying power beyond season one?
The procedural framework and shifting blame game. The show leans heavily into CSI (122)-style investigation, giving it the episodic structure networks love for multi-season runs. The Accused POV (112) keeps things fresh by constantly rotating which character seems guilty (Anna, Jack, and multiple others all look like killers at different points), a narrative trick that could sustain multiple storylines. The Lifestyle Change (110) both protagonists undergo (abandoning their carefully rebuilt lives to confront buried trauma) offers rich territory for future seasons exploring how they navigate their hometown’s shattered trust. Unlike Big Little Lies‘ laser focus on Female Friendship (155) or Stay Close‘s straightforward Serial Killer (160) hunt, His & Hers builds a revenge narrative with enough unanswered questions and damaged relationships to fuel seasons beyond the initial mystery’s resolution.

—